It's long been a trope of the "culture war" that the rich as social and religious libertines while the stolid middle class cling to traditional values. Or, as another portion of America sees it, that the educated elite have moved beyond the primative and prejudices social mores of the past while the uneducated cling to their guns and their religion. I would venture to say that for many of us reading here this may also to a stereotype which fits with our lived experience.
However, a report out from the Institute for American Values stands this set of stereotypes somewhat on its head, showing a educated elite which is going to church more and sleeping around less, while the broad middle class is going to church less, having more children out of wedlock and getting divorced more often.
One thing to keep in mind in looking at this is that the report's definition of the broad middle class is all those adults who have completed high school but have not completed a four year college degree (people with just a high school diploma, an AA or "some college"). This makes up 58% of the US population -- something which I find myself liable to forget since not getting at bachelor's degree was virtually unthinkable in my family. Both my parents had been the first in their families to earn college degrees and they believed very strongly in the importance of higher education. But while Dad's community college staff salary (plus 1-2 part time side jobs at a given time) put us squarely in the middle of the population by income demographic, this survey would have put us in the "highly educated" upper class -- those with a four year college degree or beyond, making up roughly 30% of the US population. The "less educated" in this study are composed of those without a high school diploma. Thus, this is playing somewhat outside the set of class definitions which I normally think in terms of -- which realistically are more like sub-divisions of the middle and upper middle classes.
Still, the data is fairly startling and speaks well for itself, which given a lack of time this morning, I will let it do.
Percentage of people who say they consider pre-marital sex to be "always wrong" by educational demographic, 1970s vs. 2000s:
Percentage of women who bear children out of wedlock by educational demographic, 1970s vs. 2000s:
Percentage of people aged 25 to 70 who are in an intact first marriage by educational demographic, 1970s vs. 2000s:
Percentage of people who say divorces should be made more difficult to obtain by educational demographic, 1970s vs. 2000s:
Percentage of people who "almost always" attend religious services at least once a week by educational demographic, 1970s vs. 2000s:
Ross Douthat has some interesting things to say on it.
I'm trying to formulate what this tells us about the state of our culture, but it's certainly interesting. Thoughts?
I haven't had my coffee, but don't these graphs need titles?
ReplyDeleteIf you put your cursor over the graphic, you can see the title in the link.
ReplyDeleteI thought the titles were embedded with the graphs and posted without previewing. Added them back in.
ReplyDeleteSorry... (Go have some coffee anyway, though. NASA just found caffeine based life or something.)
My best guess is the we are seeing the economics of family breakdown at work. It is harder to get an education if you are a single parent. It is harder to provide your children with an education if you are a single parent.
ReplyDelete--> Over time, people who follow traditional morality will, everything else equal, be wealthier than those who do not. Whether you espouse the beliefs because they are right, or only because they are useful.
Either way, the values divide between haves and have-nots seems to me a fairly predictable thing, economically.
The first two graphs are the most interesting to me. The first one says that only 21% of educated people regard premarital sex as wrong, which jives pretty well with another study I saw somewhere saying that only about 10% of people are virgins on their wedding nights. (Yes, these numbers align very well - some people believe it is wrong but do it anyway.)
ReplyDeleteThe second graph points out something I have long suspected: while educated people have at least as much premarital sex as everybody else (see first graph), they are far, far less likely to have unwanted pregnancies. I see two explanations: 1) Educated people are much more careful about using condoms and other forms of birth control; and 2) if a pregnancy results anyway, educated people are more likely to abort.
Joel
Joel,
ReplyDeleteI also think that educated people are more likely to get married if the women gets pregnant. Of course this is just anecdotal, but the friends that I had in college (and those that I knew that went onto law school) that got pregnant out of wedlock, all married their partner. In fact, all those marriages are still intact today (I'm 44).
JMB