I think one of the more important things for anyone interested in politics to remember is: Most voters do not have coherent or systematic political beliefs. They vote on basic things like "is the economy doing well" or "should we be in this war".
Based on the election results, factions with systematic political beliefs claim to have won and attempt to implement their goals, but most people voting in the election are not adherents to any of the political belief systems on offer.
Most people are not democratic socialists or neoliberal or Reaganites or national conservatives or libertarians or any of the other belief systems on offer. They don't know what those things are, and even though people who adhere to one of those systems may win, that's not because voters understand and agree with them.
This is one of the difficulties of democracy. The majority of the people who are voting do not necessarily know or care about a lot of the beliefs espoused by the people who win and govern. And yet, who wins and governs is determined by the voting.
But if it seems like it's incoherent that roughly the same population (accounting for changes in who shows up to vote) voted for Bush, Obama, Trump, Biden, Trump again, and now this congress, that's simply because most voters (and certainly the ones who swing elections) aren't voting on a clear ideology.
Now that doesn't mean that one shouldn't have coherent political beliefs or that it's good that most voters don't. I think it would be far better if most voters were weighing various political philosophies and coming to the right conclusions (especially if they are the ones I think are the right conclusions.) But I think it's important for both winners and losers to keep a sense of realism that when they win a particular election, that usually doesn't mean that the voters who supported them are fully on board with their ideology and willing to put up with reversals in order to see it implemented.
It also means one should not despair when people you believe hold a pernicious set of beliefs win an election. I recall both in 2016 and 2024 various people saying, "I hadn't realized that half our country support authoritarianism and racism." There's a whole separate argument about the extent to which these people were right about what Trump himself stood for, but the key point I want to make here is that it would be wrong to assume that simply because one thinks Trump was racist and authoritarian doesn't mean that the people who voted for him thought he was or that they voted for him in order to lend support to those beliefs.
Or to take the other sides worries: people who voted for Harris or Biden didn't necessarily do so because they wanted abortions up until birth or children being brainwashed into doubting their genders.
The reason voters vote for candidates does not necessarily align with the views those candidates themselves endorse or that cause their opponents to reject them.
And so while "elections have consequences" and those who win will reasonably try to do what they think is right, everyone should also proceed with a lot of humility about how much voters actually endorse any particular set of views.
Mufti Reading in his Prayer Stool
1 hour ago






No comments:
Post a Comment