Because most philosophies that frown on reproduction don't survive.

Thursday, March 28, 2013

Make Me a Channel of Peace, as St. Francis Never Said

Simcha Fisher wrote about misattributions, deliberate or no, and referenced the Peace Prayer of St. Francis, which is NOT by St. Francis, and behold, in her combox someone gives a source:

Posted by Mr Joseph G Mulvihill on Tuesday, Mar 26, 2013 1:06 PM (EDT): 
On the origin of the “Prayer of St. Francis”:
“Origin of this Prayer 
The first appearance of the Peace Prayer occurred in France in 1912 in a small spiritual magazine called La Clochette (The Little Bell). It was published in Paris by a Catholic association known as La Ligue de la Sainte-Messe (The Holy Mass League), founded in 1901 by a French priest, Father Esther Bouquerel (1855-1923). The prayer bore the title of ‘Belle prière à faire pendant la messe’ (A Beautiful Prayer to Say During the Mass), and was published anonymously. The author could possibly have been Father Bouquerel himself, but the identity of the author remains a mystery. 
The prayer was sent in French to Pope Benedict XV in 1915 by the French Marquis Stanislas de La Rochethulon. This was soon followed by its 1916 appearance, in Italian, in L’Osservatore Romano [the Vatican’s daily newspaper]. Around 1920, the prayer was printed by a French Franciscan priest on the back of an image of St. Francis with the title ‘Prière pour la paix’ (Prayer for Peace) but without being attributed to the saint. Between the two world wars, the prayer circulated in Europe and was translated into English. Its has been attributed the first time to saint Francis in 1927 by a French Protestant Movement, Les Chevaliers du Prince de la Paix (The Knights of the Prince of Peace), founded by Étienne Bach (1892-1986). 
The first translation in English that we know of appeared in 1936 in Living Courageously, a book by Kirby Page (1890-1957), a Disciple of Christ minister, pacifist, social evangelist, writer and editor of The World Tomorrow (New York City). Page clearly attributed the text to St. Francis of Assisi. During World War II and immediately after, this prayer for peace began circulating widely as the Prayer of St. Francis, specially through Francis cardinal Spellman’s books, and over the years has gained a worldwide popularity with people of all faiths. 
For more information : see the book by Dr. Christian Renoux, La prière pour la paix attribuée à saint François : une énigme à résoudre, Paris, Editions franciscaines, 2001, 210 p. : 12.81 euros + shipping (ISBN : 2-85020-096-4).—Order From: Éditions franciscaines, 9, rue Marie-Rose F-75014 Paris. 
Author’s Note: Dr. Christian Renoux, is continuing his research on the propagation of this prayer, and is looking for new information about its publication in English between 1925 and 1945, and in all other languages between 1912 and today. If you have such information, please contact him at contacted at this email address.
The Franciscan Archive wishes to thank Dr. Renoux for permission to publish the Original Text of this very popular Prayer and the history of its origin.” 
Read more:
All right, so I'm quoting from a combox to refute a misattribution, but the sources are laid out for anyone to consult or refute:

1 comment:

Donald R. McClarey said...

He also never said "Preach the Gospel. Use words if necessary."

In the age of the internet fake quotes can achieve a surface respectability over night because so many people cite it unthinkingly and spread it like crab grass. Fake quotes are a major pet peeve of mine.